Shivering Thermogenesis: Physiology and Data
Shivering increases metabolic rate 2–5-fold above resting, generating heat primarily in skeletal muscle. Threshold: core temp below ~36°C or skin temp below 25°C. Cold-acclimatized individuals exhibit more non-shivering thermogenesis and less shivering.
| Measure | Value | Unit | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Metabolic rate increase (maximal shivering) | 2–5× | above resting | Castellani & Young 2016; max ~400–500 W in cold-adapted adults |
| Shivering onset threshold (core) | ~35.5–36 | °C | Hypothalamic set-point; varies ±0.5°C between individuals |
| Shivering onset threshold (skin) | ~25 | °C | Mean skin temperature; integrated with core temperature signal |
| Primary fuel for shivering | Muscle glycogen + lipids | Muscle glycogen initially; blood glucose and fatty acids sustain prolonged shivering | |
| Duration before glycogen depletion | 1–3 | hours | Depends on glycogen stores, shivering intensity, and fat availability |
| Shivering frequency | 4–8 | cycles/sec | Rhythmic bursting pattern; coordinates across muscle groups |
| Heat generation efficiency | ~80 | % of metabolic rate → heat | Vs typical exercise where mechanical work consumes ~25% of energy |
Shivering is the body’s primary rapid-response thermogenesis mechanism — involuntary, rhythmic muscle contractions that generate heat through mechanical energy dissipation. Unlike brown adipose tissue thermogenesis, which operates silently at the cellular level, shivering is a gross motor response visible from outside.
Neural Control
The hypothalamus integrates two temperature signals:
| Signal | Location | Weight in Shivering Control |
|---|---|---|
| Core temperature | Preoptic area (hypothalamus) | ~80% of shivering signal |
| Skin temperature | Peripheral thermoreceptors → spinal cord → hypothalamus | ~20% of shivering signal |
The preoptic area of the hypothalamus contains warm-sensitive neurons that tonically inhibit shivering centers in the posterior hypothalamus and brainstem. When core temperature falls, this inhibition weakens and shivering circuits activate.
Skin temperature plays a modulatory role: cold skin can trigger shivering even before core temperature drops, serving as an early warning system.
Metabolic Data
| Shivering Intensity | Metabolic Rate | Example Context |
|---|---|---|
| Minimal (thermogenesis stage 1) | 1.2–1.5× RMR | Sitting in 15°C room |
| Moderate | 2–3× RMR | Cold water immersion, 10 min |
| Vigorous (maximal shivering) | 4–5× RMR | Extended cold stress, core cooling |
RMR = resting metabolic rate (~70 W for average adult). Maximal shivering can reach ~350–500 W of heat production.
Fuel Sources
Shivering depends on available substrates:
- Immediate (first 30 min): Muscle glycogen (fast, anaerobic pathway contributes early)
- Extended (30 min–2 hours): Blood glucose and circulating fatty acids
- Prolonged (>2 hours): Lipid mobilization from subcutaneous and intramuscular fat becomes dominant
Blondin et al. (2014) demonstrated that intramyocellular lipid contributes substantially to prolonged shivering — challenging the earlier view that shivering is primarily a glucose-dependent process.
Shivering vs Non-Shivering Thermogenesis
| Feature | Shivering | Non-Shivering Thermogenesis (NST) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary tissue | Skeletal muscle | Brown adipose tissue, beige fat |
| Speed of onset | Fast (seconds to minutes) | Slower (minutes to hours) |
| Maximum capacity | Higher in cold-naive | Enhanced with cold acclimatization |
| Efficiency | High (heat per unit metabolic cost) | Moderate |
| Visibility | Observable | Invisible |
| Metabolic pathway | ATP hydrolysis in myosin ATPase | UCP1 proton uncoupling |
Cold-acclimatized individuals rely proportionally more on NST and less on shivering — their enhanced BAT and beige fat generate sufficient heat at lower temperature thresholds, reducing the need for gross muscle contraction.
Post-Shivering Thermogenesis
After shivering ceases, metabolic rate remains elevated for 30–60 minutes via increased mitochondrial activity and residual hormonal stimulation. This “afterdrop” period of elevated thermogenesis contributes to total cold-induced energy expenditure beyond the shivering episode itself.
Related Pages
Sources
- Castellani JW & Young AJ (2016) — Human physiological responses to cold exposure. Auton Neurosci
- Blondin DP et al. (2014) — Contribution of ectopic fat to whole-body energy expenditure during prolonged shivering. J Physiol
- Janský L (1995) — Humoral thermogenesis and its role in maintaining energy balance. Physiol Rev
- Nakamura K (2011) — Central circuitries for body temperature regulation and fever. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol